By Courtney’s request, my review of last night’s Grey’s Anatomy. I get it, I’m a total squeeing fangirl, and I’ll like most of what is put in front of me so long as I have my happy Mer/Der, but I’ll try to give a good evaluation.
First off, I need to get this timeline thing off my chest. There’s an entire thread devoted to timeline issues on Television Without Pity, but it was WAY ridiculous last night, so befuddling actually that I assume Shonda wrote it just to fuck with people who whine about the timeline. I’m whining anyway. If the show started in 2005 on the interns’ first day, we’ll go with that.
Julyish 05 - First day
Julyish 06 - first day of s4
October 06 - “Haunt You Everyday” - the halloween episode
at most Mid-November 06 - Derekand Meredith break up
6 weeks later - Mer’s in therapy and bearguy comes in, clinical trial patients are gathered
One month later (January?) - Bearattack guy’s surgery, Also when Greta goes on her cruise with her possibly fictional/tumor induced boyfriend
5 months later (May 07) - Greta’s surgery. Also - before this, we see Addison and Callie eating lunch outside the hospital and there are leaves on trees and short sleeves abound. Interesting because Derek has a winter scarf on in the elevator, and everyone else is also dressed for the cold.
Maybe another month of the clinical trial, just to be totally fast - Mer/Der reunite, but Chief’s got a coat in his arm, and Meredith goes to Derek’s trailer and needs a sweater.
So now tell me this. How the fuck is it FALL in Seattle with SNOW, and it seems to be Fall ‘06 again, specifically midway through their second year. Disbelief, I’m suspending it. Fine.
Shonda’s so meta!
Tonight’s episode was a huge conversation with Shonda to the fans and critics. Even in her blog today, she said that every word written had a meaning for the season. Until ratings change your mind, right Shonda?
Seattle Grace/Grey’s Anatomy has gone from the #1 program to #12 in rankings/nielsens. Chief/Shonda says that everyone’s on notice because the doctors/writers have gotten lazy. That they were once this unknown and then got huge and rested on their laurels, but that it was changing. They are going back to basics. Basically, this was a slate-wiping episode for Shonda and Co. to highlight where they screwed up and send it off into the light, like Denny.
One choice meta-moment though was Alex ignoring Izzie. He was hoping she’d get annoyed by the sound of her own voice and shut up. You hear that Heigl? That was the writers getting you back a little.
Dream a Little Dream of Me
That was the title of the episode and there were three dreams that occurred.
Dream 1 - Meredith has a recurring nightmare where she waits for Derek in the house of candles, except he’s hit by a bus and dies. Got it. Shonda said at the end of last season, and was just doing a big fake out like Rose does to Derek does to Meredith throughout the episode. She loves him, she’s scared to lose him.
Dream 2 - Cris wipes out on the ice and dreams of her and Mer in their elderly years in Meredith’s house where Cristina has to still do everything for her. I just find it annoying that Mer of S1/2 never needed anyone to do things for her, and clearly Cristina has a fear of winding up in a platonic life partnership with Meredith.
Dream 3 - Izzie sees Alex making out with some one night stand, as he looks her right in the eye. She momentarily flashes back to riding the elevator in season 2 in her prom dress, except when the doors open, Denny is there, and they walk off into the light together.
Clearly all three dreams are things that are not going to happen. Can Denny PLEASE stay dead now? I love Jeffrey Dean Morgan, I do, but truly, Shonda should have thought about that before killing his hot ass off.
Let’s go around the horn with the cast
Izzie - Why does she get so bent out of shape for Meredith saying to Alex that he is a good guy. Whatever. At least she wasn’t much in the episode and she also thinks Derek is a good guy. We’ll see how good she thinks he is on 10/2 when Derek wants Alex and Izzie to move out. She was fine, and mostly out of the way, where she should remain.
Chief - He went soft because MEREDITH is in the program? That’s like McCain trying to get out of the debate to work on the economy. Chief never seems to think things through and when he gets nervous, he goes by the seat of his pants. Glad Derek called him on it. I did like the speech at the end though, even if it was, and maybe because it was Shonda speaking through him, admitting they’ve all been lazy.
George - Was George even in the episode? I’m fine actually with the role he played. Boy gets too much tail and screentime as it was, and he was a non-event this week.
Bailey - Kinda like George, she just wasn’t around very much.
Rose - They didn’t need her to go all bunny-boiler, but whatever. Bitch is gone.
Alex - I get it, and as I discussed with Bleu, he’s much like a male version of Meredith. One step forward, two steps back. He tries to hide it, but he really is a good guy. Much like trying to find a way to save bartender Joe’s life, he does it again with the insurance issue along side Bailey for his patient. And as much as cheating is despicable, I do like the speech he gave about why men cheat. It was heartfelt and makes me eager to watch him grow up this season.
Callica (Callie/Erica) - OH I GET IT! Callie was experimenting in the OR and in the bedroom with Hahn! How clever! I will admit that it wasn’t done up like Gizzie from last year, as I was fearing it would. I’m also heterosexual and am in no position to take offense to the fact that two adult women falling in love with each other with no other interest in women may cause. I’m reserving judgment on this ’ship until it is developed further. Hate Callie’s hair straight. Love Hahn’s curly. Also on Hahn, loved her clinical approach to learning how to teach - and in the end she just figured out a way when the pressure was on for Callie. Cliche, but I can deal.
Mark/Lexie - Adorable. “You’re my half sister’s best friend, so…” “You thought that means that we’re friends?”. He took on the role of big brother, and sassed her lots. I loved every minute of their childish teasing. It was very sweet.
Lexie - Please tell me that Lexie is gonna learn from George’s mistake and NOT pursue him just because she wants him (like he admits to doing with Meredith). I’ve really come to love Lexie Grey. Chyler is really playing her in a fun manner with great comic awkwardness (like when she was reading the letter from the husband to the wife).
Cristina/Owen - Hot. Hot hot hot. Cristina has always scoped out her men in advance, like CardioGod dude and Burke. This guy is a surprise to her and challenges her thinking, and she admits to her own mistakes in front of him. It’s a new side of Cristina that I knew was there, and was happy to see. I’m glad we’ll be seeing more of it this season.
Meredith/Cristina - Again, I have professed my undying love for Meredith. Tonight they wrote her over the top, and I hope it was just to make a point. If Meredith were my friend, I’d want her to shit or get off the pot too, as much as it pains me to say. Though I agree with Meredith that Cris’ slipping on the ice was kinda karma. My thought, last season Cristina outright told Derek that she didn’t like him, this is how that gets resolved so that she can be supportive moving forward. I look forward to a return to S2 when Burke is bossing around Derek and Cris says to Meredith, “Mine’s bigger thank youuuuurs” with Derek and Hunt.
Derek/Mark - Best Bromance EVER. The two of them could just trade barbs all day and I’d be content to watch. I will relay my favorite scene of the night:
Mark: What happened to your hand?
Derek: Scalpel…Rose…Not intentional.
Mark: She’s a dead mouse on the kitchen floor, at some point you gotta pick it up and throw it away.
Derek: Mmm.
Mark: Want me to take a look at that?
Derek: Mer’s gonna take care of it. (my note - SQUEEEE)
Mark: I’m a renowned plastic surgeon.
Derek: It’s just a scratch.
Mark: She’s a resident.
Derek (very I know where my bread is buttered look on his face): She gives me sex…especially when I’m wounded (snickers).
Also loved Mark’s line with the Chief.
Chief: Sloan - take Grey.
Mark: The good Grey?
Chief (attitude): The intern Grey.
Mer/Der - they weren’t on screen much, but what there was made me all happy and gooey and full of warm feelings. They were playful and sweet and he’s not pushing, but she’s not freaking on him when he makes a joke about getting married. Granted I thought him trying that joke on Meredith to point out what Rose had done was a bit crass to me, but Meredith was playful about it, so I’ll deal. Also, when the Chief took out all his rage on Meredith, Derek finally yelled “RICHARD” to get him to stop, and protect/stand up for Meredith. Finally, finally, finally. I also love that Meredith indicated she was still seeing Dr. Wyatt, who I believe is back next episode.
Overall a decent episode - I liked it. Not too much time spent in any one place, though I could always use more Mer/Der on the screen. Okay Shonda, you are starting over? I’m giving you some long rope. Try not to hang yourself again.
eta: Meta means self-referential. See urban dictionary.